Donderoism Lives

In the course of slamming Jesse Walker as an ignorant wingnut (seriously, Jesse frickin Walker…) for, while making a good point about politically motivated overreaction to the atrocity of the moment, accidentally omitting the Oklahoma City bombing, Tim F (one of John Cole’s co-bloggers on Balloon Juice) spews the following curiosity:

A country cannot ignore terrorist groups that are willing and able to level buildings full of innocent people. The libertarian ideal of laissez faire simply fails in this case. By the following election, if not sooner, any government that fails to respond to an assault like that will be replaced by representatives who will.

Let’s count the problems with this, shall we?

1) Unquestioning assumption that the country is synonymous with the government, despite there being no true definition of what “the people” think that would match the current government with the ideal of “representative democracy”.  If this “people w/ political power?  General public?  Same thing!” portrayal is the truth, then explain this, for example.

2) Neglect of the unfortunate fact that the description “willing and able to level buildings full of innocent people” also applies to military forces.  This is nothing new, we just know about it faster today.

3) “Lasseiz-faire” has approximately 0% to do with response to violence.  Even anarchists don’t shrug off murder, we just think the State is a terrible institution to depend on for defending against it.

4) Equating merely having a more narrow view of terrorism to completely ignoring it, and effectively co-signing the mob-rule “just DO SOMETHING!! ANYTHING!!” panic simply because it wins elections.  Nice job Tim, you’ve just embraced a view that has Karl Rove as its most prominent proponent.

This is what “mainstream” politics boils down to, folks: “endless power is good and unquestionable — as long as my side has it”.  Nothing more, nothing less.

Advertisements

About b-psycho

Left-libertarian blogger & occasional musician.
This entry was posted in fevered barking. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Donderoism Lives

  1. Scott says:

    5) Terrorist activity is at its essence a reaction against an overpowering force. If you have a beef with the neighbor, you can punch him out or take him to court. If you have a beef with an organization that has a million tentacles and controls everything around you, what can you do? So in a decentralized society where market economies of scale limit community size (and private polices agencies), you will have less concentrated force to throw around (and make enemies with).
    This is not to be naive and say that terrorism would disappear and peace on Earth would reign. But if you are worried about a hacking cough, the first step is to stop smoking.

    Besides, is a lone individual who blows up women and children morally worse than an entire group of people sanctioned by a government to do the same thing (Hiroshima)?

  2. b psycho says:

    Exactly, that’s why terrorists pick the tactics they do. To them it’s just asymmetric warfare.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s